42
edits
Talk:Discourse Modeling: Difference between revisions
Talk:Discourse Modeling (view source)
Revision as of 17:08, 12 November 2022
, 17:08, 12 November 2022→Section 1 KK
(add bulk discussion) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Section 1 KK == | == Section 1 KK == | ||
- Kyle's goals: | * - Kyle's goals: | ||
KM: build the queries needed to interact with the Discourse Graph data model | * KM: build the queries needed to interact with the Discourse Graph data model | ||
- part of the wiki and shareable | * - part of the wiki and shareable | ||
- tools: | * - tools: | ||
- wolfram/mathematica | * - wolfram/mathematica | ||
- wiki functions | * - wiki functions | ||
- integrate wolfram with semantic media wiki | * - integrate wolfram with semantic media wiki | ||
- looks possible to take the wolfram toolset & integrate it with the toolset of this wiki to accomplish the same things as wiki functions | * - looks possible to take the wolfram toolset & integrate it with the toolset of this wiki to accomplish the same things as wiki functions | ||
- namespace of functions that any contributor to functions can edit | * - namespace of functions that any contributor to functions can edit | ||
- can fork functions to create others derivative functions without disturbing the operation of the original functions | * - can fork functions to create others derivative functions without disturbing the operation of the original functions | ||
- functions could be v local - just defined by whoever is using that graph | * - functions could be v local - just defined by whoever is using that graph | ||
- KH: wikifunctions intended to be a way to add code (abstract wikipedia) write page without knowing which language it would be displayed in | * - KH: wikifunctions intended to be a way to add code (abstract wikipedia) write page without knowing which language it would be displayed in | ||
- catalogue of functions written in any language you'd like | * - catalogue of functions written in any language you'd like | ||
- KH: federated knowledge synthesis - more a meta-project, don't expect an artefact | * - KH: federated knowledge synthesis - more a meta-project, don't expect an artefact | ||
- get people together | * - get people together | ||
- do a survey of prior work (eg anagora) | * - do a survey of prior work (eg anagora) | ||
- how can we build on this and go on | * - how can we build on this and go on | ||
- more of a coordination of who is interested in doing what over the next few years | * - more of a coordination of who is interested in doing what over the next few years | ||
- federation as in federated wiki | * - federation as in federated wiki | ||
- [[question]] problem with wiki is that there is only one version of each page - what if you disagree? | * - [[question]] problem with wiki is that there is only one version of each page - what if you disagree? | ||
- [[claim]] in wiki each page has a single version --> federated wiki is the solution | * - [[claim]] in wiki each page has a single version --> federated wiki is the solution | ||
- [[claim]] pages in a federated wiki are more like working in branches as in git | * - [[claim]] pages in a federated wiki are more like working in branches as in git | ||
- [[claim]] *branches* and *merges* are important ideas in the federated wiki concept space | * - [[claim]] *branches* and *merges* are important ideas in the federated wiki concept space | ||
- (federation model) | * - (federation model) | ||
- (conflict resolution) | * - (conflict resolution) | ||
- [[claim]] we talk about DGs as if they are done by the *reader* of a paper, but at some point, *authors* will start o ut by creating DGs to which readers will respond | * - [[claim]] we talk about DGs as if they are done by the *reader* of a paper, but at some point, *authors* will start o ut by creating DGs to which readers will respond | ||
- [[question]] how can you start w something highly formalized like version control and meet in the middle at something suitable for narratives? | * - [[question]] how can you start w something highly formalized like version control and meet in the middle at something suitable for narratives? | ||
- [[evidence]] everything2 | * - [[evidence]] everything2 | ||
- [[evidence]] agora | * - [[evidence]] agora | ||
- [[question]] can we enable effective and usable graph visualizations? | * - [[question]] can we enable effective and usable graph visualizations? | ||
- [[question]] do DG graph properties scale to communally edited collaborative graphs? | * - [[question]] do DG graph properties scale to communally edited collaborative graphs? | ||
- reader --> author transition | * - reader --> author transition | ||
- [[question]] KH: will the "author" label on scientific papers disappear as collaborations grow? | * - [[question]] KH: will the "author" label on scientific papers disappear as collaborations grow? | ||
- SJ: what types of graph are we talking about? | * - SJ: what types of graph are we talking about? | ||
- I haven't seen dgs about discourse: chains of reasoning, mapping out arguments - these can be linear if there is a dialog | * - I haven't seen dgs about discourse: chains of reasoning, mapping out arguments - these can be linear if there is a dialog | ||
- composite graph of discourse addressing the same issues | * - composite graph of discourse addressing the same issues | ||
- personal or group notetaking: connections are not discourse connections | * - personal or group notetaking: connections are not discourse connections | ||
- reference | * - reference | ||
- clarifiers | * - clarifiers | ||
- links of definitions | * - links of definitions | ||
== Section 2 Konrad == | == Section 2 Konrad == | ||