Synthesis Infrastructures - User contributions [en]

Synthesizing Social Media/First Breakout Session

2022-11-12T17:35:01Z

Ronent: /* Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension */

Back up to [[Part of::Synthesizing Social Media]]

== Possible Topics ==

* [[ActivityPub]] with [[Linked Data]]??
* Using [[Braid]] - https://braid.org/point
* [[A System for Interleaving Discussion and Summarization in Online Collaboration]]

== Patching on top of masto ==

=== First pass ===

* Using the profile tags to be able to assign prefixes to a digital object
** So say i have <code>paper:paper url</code> in my profile
* Then being able to refer to that object using @jonny:paper in a post
* And then posts beneath that use that as the subject when resolving [ [Semantic::wikilinks] ]

=== Second pass ===

* Metadata tag in masto profile that links to a wiki page
** <code>wiki:https://synthesis-infrastuctures.wiki/Jonny_Saunders</code>
* Page has a series of [[Property:Tag]] annotatations that link a short tag to a further page or URL. The linked page could have additional metadata like DOIs, authors, etc.
** <nowiki>[[Tag::shortname::Longer Page Name]]</nowiki>
* Posting a thread with the first post using a syntax like <code>@jonny:wiki:shortname</code> then treats posts underneath that as having that as the subject, and a bot then scoops those up and puts them in the page enabling the use of semantic wikilinks, etc.
* A bot then is monitoring opt-in accounts for these kinds of threads and exporting them to the relevant wiki page as subpages containing the threads.
** Like the [[WikiBot]], additional [[Wikilinks]] within the thread also embed a link to the thread (probably want to have the thread be its own page then, and have some syntax for declaring a title)
* The bot could also have interoperable export formats out to [[Braid]], etc.

==== TODO during the workshop ====

* Deploy a glitch-soc instance in the synthesis-infrastructures domain to test
* Write the above bot and make relevant wiki components :)

==== Further integration into client ====
* UX elements to be able to select and resolve tags for a given author within the instance that has enabled this syntax.
* An overlay could search for linked wikis and work backwards - so given a DOI, find the page with the <nowiki>[[Has DOI::...]]</nowiki> page and then overlay the threads underneath it.

== Use cases ==

* Shorthand identifiers using profile metadata (as above)
* Using semantic links in streams headed by shorthand identifiers
* [[Attention]] data on reading: taking eg. zotero and converting that to a post stream or something

=== Mastodon/Twitter Paper announcement use case ===

* One of the common norms that have developed on academic social media (Twitter/Mastodon) is announcement/summary threads of one’s paper. e.g.: https://hci.social/web/@Mor/109309396530932422 (others of interest: job market announcements, taking PhD announcements)
* Imagine if you could create for yourself a unique, short, readable identifier for a paper, and add that in your post thread about your paper announcement.
** Possible syntax:
*** <code>@mor:crisis-informatics</code> user namespace
**** downsides: there are multiple authors, so an author may feel left out if another author's id gets used more often or authors could coalesce around one author (ie, 1st author)
*** <code><nowiki>#</nowiki>cscw22:crisis-informatics</code> conference namespace
**** downsides: possibility for name conflicts, you could use the conference ID but it's not very readable
* Things you could do as a result:
** Presentation: put all your different paper threads on your academic webpage and associated with each paper, for example
** Synthesis: collect all the paper announcements for a conference/topic and organize/synthesize it using other tools
** Discussion: people could reference your identifier in their conversations, and a bot could post the paper announcement thread as a reply (https://hci.social/web/@lewischuang/109331737391363720)
** Discussion: you could collect all discussion around your paper in a separate place, or a bot could post pingbacks on the original paper announcement thread

=== Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension ===
* Attention data (~digital pheromone trails) is an important step in the knowledge synthesis pipeline- what am I looking at and my assessment of it
* Sharing attention data using linked data over ActivityPub-
** Pros- catching Mastodon wave, good expressivity but
** Cons- writing it manually creates friction and so reduces usage by researchers
* An extension can create automatic linked data posts based on existing user activity in Zotero
** Adding a paper to a reading list
** Tagging
** Annotating inline, connecting pieces to other papers
** Reviewing/assessing/endorsing content
* Question - what are interesting downstream applications for attention data?
** Content recommendation
** Layering paper viewers with endorsements/reviews, popular tags & annotations
*References
**[https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/2818048.2819949 Opportunities and Challenges Around a Tool for Social and Public Web Activity Tracking]
**[https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3511095.3536361 From Users to (Sense)Makers: On the Pivotal Role of Stigmergic Social Annotation in the Quest for Collective Sensemaking]

[[Category:Conversation]]

Synthesizing Social Media/First Breakout Session

2022-11-12T17:22:32Z

Ronent: /* Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension */

Back up to [[Part of::Synthesizing Social Media]]

== Possible Topics ==

* [[ActivityPub]] with [[Linked Data]]??
* Using [[Braid]] - https://braid.org/point
* [[A System for Interleaving Discussion and Summarization in Online Collaboration]]

== Patching on top of masto ==

=== First pass ===

* Using the profile tags to be able to assign prefixes to a digital object
** So say i have <code>paper:paper url</code> in my profile
* Then being able to refer to that object using @jonny:paper in a post
* And then posts beneath that use that as the subject when resolving [ [Semantic::wikilinks] ]

=== Second pass ===

* Metadata tag in masto profile that links to a wiki page
** <code>wiki:https://synthesis-infrastuctures.wiki/Jonny_Saunders</code>
* Page has a series of [[Property:Tag]] annotatations that link a short tag to a further page or URL. The linked page could have additional metadata like DOIs, authors, etc.
** <nowiki>[[Tag::shortname::Longer Page Name]]</nowiki>
* Posting a thread with the first post using a syntax like <code>@jonny:wiki:shortname</code> then treats posts underneath that as having that as the subject, and a bot then scoops those up and puts them in the page enabling the use of semantic wikilinks, etc.
* A bot then is monitoring opt-in accounts for these kinds of threads and exporting them to the relevant wiki page as subpages containing the threads.
** Like the [[WikiBot]], additional [[Wikilinks]] within the thread also embed a link to the thread (probably want to have the thread be its own page then, and have some syntax for declaring a title)
* The bot could also have interoperable export formats out to [[Braid]], etc.

==== TODO during the workshop ====

* Deploy a glitch-soc instance in the synthesis-infrastructures domain to test
* Write the above bot and make relevant wiki components :)

==== Further integration into client ====
* UX elements to be able to select and resolve tags for a given author within the instance that has enabled this syntax.
* An overlay could search for linked wikis and work backwards - so given a DOI, find the page with the <nowiki>[[Has DOI::...]]</nowiki> page and then overlay the threads underneath it.

== Use cases ==

* Shorthand identifiers using profile metadata (as above)
* Using semantic links in streams headed by shorthand identifiers
* [[Attention]] data on reading: taking eg. zotero and converting that to a post stream or something

=== Mastodon/Twitter Paper announcement use case ===

* One of the common norms that have developed on academic social media (Twitter/Mastodon) is announcement/summary threads of one’s paper. e.g.: <nowiki>https://hci.social/web/@Mor/109309396530932422</nowiki> (others of interest: job market announcements, taking PhD announcements)
* Imagine if you could create for yourself a unique, short, readable identifier for a paper, and add that in your post thread about your paper announcement.
** Possible syntax:
*** @mor:crisis-informatics //user namespace
**** downsides: there are multiple authors, so an author may feel left out if another author's id gets used more often
*** <nowiki>#</nowiki>cscw22:crisis-informatics //conference namespace
**** downsides: possibility for name conflicts, you could use the conference ID but it's not very readable
* Things you could do as a result:
** Presentation: put all your different paper threads on your academic webpage and associated with each paper, for example
** Synthesis: collect all the paper announcements for a conference/topic and organize/synthesize it using other tools
** Discussion: people could reference your identifier in their conversations, and a bot could post the paper announcement thread as a reply (<nowiki>https://hci.social/web/@lewischuang/109331737391363720</nowiki>)
** Discussion: you could collect all discussion around your paper in a separate place, or a bot could post pingbacks on the original paper announcement thread

=== Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension ===
* Attention data (~digital pheromone trails) is an important step in the knowledge synthesis pipeline- what am I looking at and my assessment of it
* Linked data over ActivityPub-
** Pros- catching Mastodon wave, good expressivity but
** Cons- writing it manually creates friction and so reduces usage by researchers
* An extension can create automatic linked data posts based on existing user activity in Zotero
** Adding a paper to a reading list
** Tagging
** Annotating inline, connecting pieces to other papers
** Reviewing/assessing/endorsing content
* Question - what are interesting downstream applications for attention data?
** Content recommendation
** Layering paper viewers with endorsements/reviews, popular tags & annotations

[[Category:Conversation]]

Synthesizing Social Media/First Breakout Session

2022-11-12T17:22:08Z

Ronent: /* Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension */

Back up to [[Part of::Synthesizing Social Media]]

== Possible Topics ==

* [[ActivityPub]] with [[Linked Data]]??
* Using [[Braid]] - https://braid.org/point
* [[A System for Interleaving Discussion and Summarization in Online Collaboration]]

== Patching on top of masto ==

=== First pass ===

* Using the profile tags to be able to assign prefixes to a digital object
** So say i have <code>paper:paper url</code> in my profile
* Then being able to refer to that object using @jonny:paper in a post
* And then posts beneath that use that as the subject when resolving [ [Semantic::wikilinks] ]

=== Second pass ===

* Metadata tag in masto profile that links to a wiki page
** <code>wiki:https://synthesis-infrastuctures.wiki/Jonny_Saunders</code>
* Page has a series of [[Property:Tag]] annotatations that link a short tag to a further page or URL. The linked page could have additional metadata like DOIs, authors, etc.
** <nowiki>[[Tag::shortname::Longer Page Name]]</nowiki>
* Posting a thread with the first post using a syntax like <code>@jonny:wiki:shortname</code> then treats posts underneath that as having that as the subject, and a bot then scoops those up and puts them in the page enabling the use of semantic wikilinks, etc.
* A bot then is monitoring opt-in accounts for these kinds of threads and exporting them to the relevant wiki page as subpages containing the threads.
** Like the [[WikiBot]], additional [[Wikilinks]] within the thread also embed a link to the thread (probably want to have the thread be its own page then, and have some syntax for declaring a title)
* The bot could also have interoperable export formats out to [[Braid]], etc.

==== TODO during the workshop ====

* Deploy a glitch-soc instance in the synthesis-infrastructures domain to test
* Write the above bot and make relevant wiki components :)

==== Further integration into client ====
* UX elements to be able to select and resolve tags for a given author within the instance that has enabled this syntax.
* An overlay could search for linked wikis and work backwards - so given a DOI, find the page with the <nowiki>[[Has DOI::...]]</nowiki> page and then overlay the threads underneath it.

== Use cases ==

* Shorthand identifiers using profile metadata (as above)
* Using semantic links in streams headed by shorthand identifiers
* [[Attention]] data on reading: taking eg. zotero and converting that to a post stream or something

=== Mastodon/Twitter Paper announcement use case ===

* One of the common norms that have developed on academic social media (Twitter/Mastodon) is announcement/summary threads of one’s paper. e.g.: <nowiki>https://hci.social/web/@Mor/109309396530932422</nowiki> (others of interest: job market announcements, taking PhD announcements)
* Imagine if you could create for yourself a unique, short, readable identifier for a paper, and add that in your post thread about your paper announcement.
** Possible syntax:
*** @mor:crisis-informatics //user namespace
**** downsides: there are multiple authors, so an author may feel left out if another author's id gets used more often
*** <nowiki>#</nowiki>cscw22:crisis-informatics //conference namespace
**** downsides: possibility for name conflicts, you could use the conference ID but it's not very readable
* Things you could do as a result:
** Presentation: put all your different paper threads on your academic webpage and associated with each paper, for example
** Synthesis: collect all the paper announcements for a conference/topic and organize/synthesize it using other tools
** Discussion: people could reference your identifier in their conversations, and a bot could post the paper announcement thread as a reply (<nowiki>https://hci.social/web/@lewischuang/109331737391363720</nowiki>)
** Discussion: you could collect all discussion around your paper in a separate place, or a bot could post pingbacks on the original paper announcement thread

===== Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension =====

* Attention data (~digital pheromone trails) is an important step in the knowledge synthesis pipeline- what am I looking at and my assessment of it
* Linked data over ActivityPub-
** Pros- catching Mastodon wave, good expressivity but
** Cons- writing it manually creates friction and so reduces usage by researchers
* An extension can create automatic linked data posts based on existing user activity in Zotero
** Adding a paper to a reading list
** Tagging
** Annotating inline, connecting pieces to other papers
** Reviewing/assessing/endorsing content
* Question - what are interesting downstream applications for attention data?
** Content recommendation
** Layering paper viewers with endorsements/reviews, popular tags & annotations

[[Category:Conversation]]

Synthesizing Social Media/First Breakout Session

2022-11-12T17:17:43Z

Ronent: /* Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension */

Back up to [[Part of::Synthesizing Social Media]]

== Possible Topics ==

* [[ActivityPub]] with [[Linked Data]]??
* Using [[Braid]] - https://braid.org/point
* [[A System for Interleaving Discussion and Summarization in Online Collaboration]]

== Patching on top of masto ==

=== First pass ===

* Using the profile tags to be able to assign prefixes to a digital object
** So say i have <code>paper:paper url</code> in my profile
* Then being able to refer to that object using @jonny:paper in a post
* And then posts beneath that use that as the subject when resolving [ [Semantic::wikilinks] ]

=== Second pass ===

* Metadata tag in masto profile that links to a wiki page
** <code>wiki:https://synthesis-infrastuctures.wiki/Jonny_Saunders</code>
* Page has a series of [[Property:Tag]] annotatations that link a short tag to a further page or URL. The linked page could have additional metadata like DOIs, authors, etc.
** <nowiki>[[Tag::shortname::Longer Page Name]]</nowiki>
* Posting a thread with the first post using a syntax like <code>@jonny:wiki:shortname</code> then treats posts underneath that as having that as the subject, and a bot then scoops those up and puts them in the page enabling the use of semantic wikilinks, etc.
* A bot then is monitoring opt-in accounts for these kinds of threads and exporting them to the relevant wiki page as subpages containing the threads.
** Like the [[WikiBot]], additional [[Wikilinks]] within the thread also embed a link to the thread (probably want to have the thread be its own page then, and have some syntax for declaring a title)
* The bot could also have interoperable export formats out to [[Braid]], etc.

==== TODO during the workshop ====

* Deploy a glitch-soc instance in the synthesis-infrastructures domain to test
* Write the above bot and make relevant wiki components :)

==== Further integration into client ====
* UX elements to be able to select and resolve tags for a given author within the instance that has enabled this syntax.
* An overlay could search for linked wikis and work backwards - so given a DOI, find the page with the <nowiki>[[Has DOI::...]]</nowiki> page and then overlay the threads underneath it.

== Use cases ==

* Shorthand identifiers using profile metadata (as above)
* Using semantic links in streams headed by shorthand identifiers
* [[Attention]] data on reading: taking eg. zotero and converting that to a post stream or something

=== Mastodon/Twitter Paper announcement use case ===

* One of the common norms that have developed on academic social media (Twitter/Mastodon) is announcement/summary threads of one’s paper. e.g.: <nowiki>https://hci.social/web/@Mor/109309396530932422</nowiki> (others of interest: job market announcements, taking PhD announcements)
* Imagine if you could create for yourself a unique, short, readable identifier for a paper, and add that in your post thread about your paper announcement.
** Possible syntax:
*** @mor:crisis-informatics //user namespace
*** <nowiki>#</nowiki>cscw22:crisis-informatics //conference namespace
* Things you could do as a result:
** Presentation: put all your different paper threads on your academic webpage and associated with each paper
** Synthesis: collect all the paper announcements for a conference and organize/synthesize it using other tools
** Discussion: people could reference your identifier in their conversations, and a bot could post the paper announcement thread as a reply (<nowiki>https://hci.social/web/@lewischuang/109331737391363720</nowiki>)
** Discussion: you could collect all discussion around your paper in a separate place, or a bot could post pingbacks on the original paper announcement thread

===== Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension =====

* Attention data (~digital pheromone trails) is an important step in the knowledge synthesis pipeline- what am I looking at and my assessment of it
* Linked data provides great expressivity but writing it manually creates friction and so reduces usage by researchers
* An extension can create automatic linked data posts based on existing user activity in Zotero
** Adding a paper to a reading list
** Tagging
** Annotating inline, connecting pieces to other papers
** Reviewing/assessing/endorsing content

[[Category:Conversation]]

Synthesizing Social Media/First Breakout Session

2022-11-12T17:17:04Z

Ronent: /* Use cases */ zotero for attention

Back up to [[Part of::Synthesizing Social Media]]

== Possible Topics ==

* [[ActivityPub]] with [[Linked Data]]??
* Using [[Braid]] - https://braid.org/point
* [[A System for Interleaving Discussion and Summarization in Online Collaboration]]

== Patching on top of masto ==

=== First pass ===

* Using the profile tags to be able to assign prefixes to a digital object
** So say i have <code>paper:paper url</code> in my profile
* Then being able to refer to that object using @jonny:paper in a post
* And then posts beneath that use that as the subject when resolving [ [Semantic::wikilinks] ]

=== Second pass ===

* Metadata tag in masto profile that links to a wiki page
** <code>wiki:https://synthesis-infrastuctures.wiki/Jonny_Saunders</code>
* Page has a series of [[Property:Tag]] annotatations that link a short tag to a further page or URL. The linked page could have additional metadata like DOIs, authors, etc.
** <nowiki>[[Tag::shortname::Longer Page Name]]</nowiki>
* Posting a thread with the first post using a syntax like <code>@jonny:wiki:shortname</code> then treats posts underneath that as having that as the subject, and a bot then scoops those up and puts them in the page enabling the use of semantic wikilinks, etc.
* A bot then is monitoring opt-in accounts for these kinds of threads and exporting them to the relevant wiki page as subpages containing the threads.
** Like the [[WikiBot]], additional [[Wikilinks]] within the thread also embed a link to the thread (probably want to have the thread be its own page then, and have some syntax for declaring a title)
* The bot could also have interoperable export formats out to [[Braid]], etc.

==== TODO during the workshop ====

* Deploy a glitch-soc instance in the synthesis-infrastructures domain to test
* Write the above bot and make relevant wiki components :)

==== Further integration into client ====
* UX elements to be able to select and resolve tags for a given author within the instance that has enabled this syntax.
* An overlay could search for linked wikis and work backwards - so given a DOI, find the page with the <nowiki>[[Has DOI::...]]</nowiki> page and then overlay the threads underneath it.

== Use cases ==

* Shorthand identifiers using profile metadata (as above)
* Using semantic links in streams headed by shorthand identifiers
* [[Attention]] data on reading: taking eg. zotero and converting that to a post stream or something

=== Mastodon/Twitter Paper announcement use case ===

* One of the common norms that have developed on academic social media (Twitter/Mastodon) is announcement/summary threads of one’s paper. e.g.: <nowiki>https://hci.social/web/@Mor/109309396530932422</nowiki> (others of interest: job market announcements, taking PhD announcements)
* Imagine if you could create for yourself a unique, short, readable identifier for a paper, and add that in your post thread about your paper announcement.
** Possible syntax:
*** @mor:crisis-informatics //user namespace
*** <nowiki>#</nowiki>cscw22:crisis-informatics //conference namespace
* Things you could do as a result:
** Presentation: put all your different paper threads on your academic webpage and associated with each paper
** Synthesis: collect all the paper announcements for a conference and organize/synthesize it using other tools
** Discussion: people could reference your identifier in their conversations, and a bot could post the paper announcement thread as a reply (<nowiki>https://hci.social/web/@lewischuang/109331737391363720</nowiki>)
** Discussion: you could collect all discussion around your paper in a separate place, or a bot could post pingbacks on the original paper announcement thread

===== Sharing attention data on ActivityPub through Zotero (?) extension =====

* Attention data (~digital pheromone trails) is an important step in the knowledge synthesis pipeline- what am I looking at and my assessment of it
* Linked data provides great expressivity but writing it manually creates friction and so reduces usage by researchers
* An extension can create automatic linked data posts based on existing workflows
** Adding a paper to a reading list
** Tagging
** Annotating inline, connecting pieces to other papers
** Reviewing/assessing/endorsing content

[[Category:Conversation]]

Open Source Attention

2022-11-12T14:45:27Z

Ronent:

From our [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]'s abstract:<blockquote>The web has become a dominant epistemic environment, influencing people's beliefs at a global scale. However, online epistemic environments are increasingly polluted, impairing societies' ability to coordinate effectively in the face of global crises. We argue that centralized platforms are a main source of epistemic pollution, and that healthier environments require redesigning how we collectively govern attention. Inspired by decentralization and open source software movements, we propose '''Open Source Attention''', a socio-technical framework for "freeing" human attention from control by platforms, through a decentralized eco-system for creating, storing and querying stigmergic markers; the digital traces of human attention.</blockquote>And also - [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be 3-min video], [https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 Twitter thread]{{Project
|Homepage=https://www.csensemakers.com/
|Description=
|Repository URL=
}}

Open Source Attention

2022-11-12T14:43:19Z

Ronent: Added abstract

From our [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]'s abstract:<blockquote>The web has become a dominant epistemic environment, influencing people's beliefs at a global scale. However, online epistemic environments are increasingly polluted, impairing societies' ability to coordinate effectively in the face of global crises. We argue that centralized platforms are a main source of epistemic pollution, and that healthier environments require redesigning how we collectively govern attention. Inspired by decentralization and open source software movements, we propose '''Open Source Attention''', a socio-technical framework for "freeing" human attention from control by platforms, through a decentralized eco-system for creating, storing and querying stigmergic markers; the digital traces of human attention.</blockquote>{{Project
|Homepage=https://www.csensemakers.com/
|Description=
|Repository URL=
}}

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-09T10:30:41Z

Ronent: /* Background */

== Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Proposer: Ronen Tamari

=== Basic idea ===

Attention data is an important and interesting signal. Platforms (e.g., Twitter, Google Scholar, Goodreads, Altmetrics) harvest large amounts of attention data, using it to drive content search and recommendation (CSR). However, this attention data remains mostly locked and inaccessible to the public.

We wish to enable users to easily publish linked data related to attention, or their '''reactions to content''' (maybe it could be called “linked attention data”? , [https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1033091723389317160/1037786518800039978 Discord discussion])

===Background===

For broad motivation, see [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]/[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be video]/[https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 thread]. And more concretely for our project, many researchers already post such “attention information”, e.g., the Tweet below.
[[File:Tweet.png|thumb|alt=Researcher tweeeting that they want to read a particular paper.|Original Tweet: https://twitter.com/adamsafron/status/1587970661397368832]]

This kind of information can be very valuable for driving content search and recommendation but it gets lost since (1) it isn’t easily machine readable (2) it gets posted to walled platforms with data access issues.

===Objective===

A possible goal for this project could be a helper app that with the click of a button (maybe a browser extension) would (1) produce some kind of machine readable representation appended to the natural language version of the post (2) publish it using ActivityPub (AP) or other related network (3) possibly mirror it to Twitter if so desired.

Another possible client implementation could be a Zotero plug-in. For example, moving an item to a particular folder or adding a particular note/tag to it could trigger the corresponding AP publishing event.

===Implementation===

Regarding data schema we can possibly use http://Schema.org schemas such as [https://schema.org/ReactAction ReactAction], [https://schema.org/ReviewAction ReviewAction]

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-09T10:29:33Z

Ronent: /* Linked Attention Data Publishing */

== Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Proposer: Ronen Tamari

=== Basic idea ===

Attention data is an important and interesting signal. Platforms (e.g., Twitter, Google Scholar, Goodreads, Altmetrics) harvest large amounts of attention data, using it to drive content search and recommendation (CSR). However, this attention data remains mostly locked and inaccessible to the public.

We wish to enable users to easily publish linked data related to attention, or their '''reactions to content''' (maybe it could be called “linked attention data”? , [https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1033091723389317160/1037786518800039978 Discord discussion])

===Background===

For broad motivation, see [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]/[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be video]/[https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 thread]. And more concretely for our project, many researchers already post such “attention information”, e.g., the Tweet below.
[[File:Tweet.png|thumb|alt=Researcher tweeeting that they want to read a particular paper.|Original Tweet: https://twitter.com/adamsafron/status/1587970661397368832]]

This information can be very valuable for driving content search and recommendation but it gets lost since (1) it isn’t easily machine readable (2) it gets posted to walled platforms with data access issues.

===Objective===

A possible goal for this project could be a helper app that with the click of a button (maybe a browser extension) would (1) produce some kind of machine readable representation appended to the natural language version of the post (2) publish it using ActivityPub (AP) or other related network (3) possibly mirror it to Twitter if so desired.

Another possible client implementation could be a Zotero plug-in. For example, moving an item to a particular folder or adding a particular note/tag to it could trigger the corresponding AP publishing event.

===Implementation===

Regarding data schema we can possibly use http://Schema.org schemas such as [https://schema.org/ReactAction ReactAction], [https://schema.org/ReviewAction ReviewAction]

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-09T10:20:25Z

Ronent: /* Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing */

== Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Proposer: Ronen Tamari

=== Basic idea ===

Enable users to easily post linked data of a particular kind pertaining to their '''reactions to content''' (maybe it could be called “linked attention data” , [https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1033091723389317160/1037786518800039978 Discord discussion])

===Motivation===

For broad motivation, see [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]/[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be video]/[https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 thread]. And more concretely for our project, many researchers already post such “attention information”, e.g., the Tweet below.
[[File:Tweet.png|thumb|alt=Researcher tweeeting that they want to read a particular paper.|Original Tweet: https://twitter.com/adamsafron/status/1587970661397368832]]

This information can be very valuable for driving content search and recommendation but it gets lost since (1) it isn’t easily machine readable (2) it gets posted to walled platforms with data access issues.

===Objective===

A possible goal for this project could be a helper app that with the click of a button (maybe a browser extension) would (1) produce some kind of machine readable representation appended to the natural language version of the post (2) publish it using ActivityPub (AP) or other related network (3) possibly mirror it to Twitter if so desired.

Another possible client implementation could be a Zotero plug-in. For example, moving an item to a particular folder or adding a particular note/tag to it could trigger the corresponding AP publishing event.

===Implementation===

Regarding data schema we can possibly use http://Schema.org schemas such as [https://schema.org/ReactAction ReactAction], [https://schema.org/ReviewAction ReviewAction]

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-09T10:20:04Z

Ronent: /* Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing */

== Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Proposer: Ronen Tamari

=== Basic idea ===

Enable users to easily post linked data of a particular kind pertaining to their '''reactions to content''' (maybe it could be called “linked attention data” , [https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1033091723389317160/1037786518800039978 Discord discussion])

===Motivation===

For broad motivation, see [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]/[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be video]/[https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 thread]. And more concretely for our project, many researchers already post such “attention information”, e.g., the Tweet below.
[[File:Tweet.png|thumb|alt=Researcher tweeeting that they want to read a particular paper.|Original Tweet: https://twitter.com/adamsafron/status/1587970661397368832]]

This information can be very valuable for driving content search and recommendation but it gets lost since (1) it isn’t easily machine readable (2) it gets posted to walled platforms with data access issues.

===Objective===

A possible goal for this project could be a helper app that with the click of a button (maybe a browser extension) would (1) produce some kind of machine readable representation appended to the natural language version of the post (2) publish it using ActivityPub (AP) or other related network (3) possibly mirror it to Twitter if so desired.

Another possible client implementation could be a Zotero plug-in. For example, moving an item to a particular folder or adding a particular note/tag to it could trigger the corresponding AP publishing event.

===Implementation===

Regarding data schema we can possibly use http://Schema.org schemas such as [https://schema.org/ReactAction ReactAction], [https://schema.org/ReviewAction ReviewAction]

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-09T10:19:53Z

Ronent: /* Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing */

== Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Proposer: Ronen Tamari

=== Basic idea ===

Enable users to easily post linked data of a particular kind pertaining to their '''reactions to content''' (maybe it could be called “linked attention data” , [https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1033091723389317160/1037786518800039978 Discord discussion])

===Motivation===

For broad motivation, see [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]/[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be video]/[https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 thread]. And more concretely for our project, many researchers already post such “attention information”, e.g., the Tweet below.
[[File:Tweet.png|thumb|alt=Researcher tweeeting that they want to read a particular paper.|Original Tweet: https://twitter.com/adamsafron/status/1587970661397368832]]

This information can be very valuable for driving content search and recommendation but it gets lost since (1) it isn’t easily machine readable (2) it gets posted to walled platforms with data access issues.

===Objective===

A possible goal for this project could be a helper app that with the click of a button (maybe a browser extension) would (1) produce some kind of machine readable representation appended to the natural language version of the post (2) publish it using ActivityPub (AP) or other related network (3) possibly mirror it to Twitter if so desired.

Another possible client implementation could be a Zotero plug-in. For example, moving an item to a particular folder or adding a particular note/tag to it could trigger the corresponding AP publishing event.

===Implementation

Regarding data schema we can possibly use http://Schema.org schemas such as [https://schema.org/ReactAction ReactAction], [https://schema.org/ReviewAction ReviewAction]

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-09T10:16:55Z

Ronent: /* Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing */

== Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Proposer: Ronen Tamari

Basic idea: enable users to easily post linked data of a particular kind pertaining to their '''reactions to content''' (maybe it could be called “linked attention data” , [https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1033091723389317160/1037786518800039978 Discord discussion])

Motivation: For broad motivation, see [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]/[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be video]/[https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 thread]. And more concretely for our project, many researchers already post such “attention information”, e.g., the Tweet below.
[[File:Tweet.png|thumb|alt=Researcher tweeeting that they want to read a particular paper.|Original Tweet: https://twitter.com/adamsafron/status/1587970661397368832]]

This information can be very valuable for driving content search and recommendation but it gets lost since (1) it isn’t easily machine readable (2) it gets posted to walled platforms with data access issues.

A possible goal for this project could be a helper app that with the click of a button (maybe a browser extension) would (1) produce some kind of machine readable representation appended to the natural language version of the post (2) publish it using ActivityPub (AP) or other related network (3) possibly mirror it to Twitter if so desired.

Another possible client implementation could be a Zotero plug-in. For example, moving an item to a particular folder or adding a particular note/tag to it could trigger the corresponding AP publishing event.

Regarding data schema we can possibly use http://Schema.org schemas such as [https://schema.org/ReactAction ReactAction], [https://schema.org/ReviewAction ReviewAction]

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-09T10:16:41Z

Ronent: /* Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing */

== Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Proposer: Ronen Tamari

Basic idea to enable users to easily post linked data of a particular kind pertaining to their '''reactions to content''' (maybe it could be called “linked attention data” , [https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1033091723389317160/1037786518800039978 Discord discussion])

Motivation: For broad motivation, see [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]/[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be video]/[https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 thread]. And more concretely for our project, many researchers already post such “attention information”, e.g., the Tweet below.
[[File:Tweet.png|thumb|alt=Researcher tweeeting that they want to read a particular paper.|Original Tweet: https://twitter.com/adamsafron/status/1587970661397368832]]

This information can be very valuable for driving content search and recommendation but it gets lost since (1) it isn’t easily machine readable (2) it gets posted to walled platforms with data access issues.

A possible goal for this project could be a helper app that with the click of a button (maybe a browser extension) would (1) produce some kind of machine readable representation appended to the natural language version of the post (2) publish it using ActivityPub (AP) or other related network (3) possibly mirror it to Twitter if so desired.

Another possible client implementation could be a Zotero plug-in. For example, moving an item to a particular folder or adding a particular note/tag to it could trigger the corresponding AP publishing event.

Regarding data schema we can possibly use http://Schema.org schemas such as [https://schema.org/ReactAction ReactAction], [https://schema.org/ReviewAction ReviewAction]

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-09T10:14:36Z

Ronent: /* Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing */

== Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Proposer: Ronen Tamari

Basic idea to enable users to easily post linked data of a particular kind pertaining to their '''reactions to content''' (maybe it could be called “linked attention data” , [https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1033091723389317160/1037786518800039978 Discord discussion])

Motivation: For broad motivation, see [https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.06345 paper]/[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQerH4kCaSA&feature=youtu.be video]/[https://twitter.com/rtk254/status/1528742051461865472 thread]. And more concretely for our project, many researchers already post such “attention information”, e.g., below:
[[File:Tweet.png|thumb|alt=Researcher tweeeting that they want to read a particular paper.|Original Tweet: https://twitter.com/adamsafron/status/1587970661397368832]]

This information can be very valuable for driving content search and recommendation but it gets lost since (1) it isn’t easily machine readable (2) it gets posted to walled platforms with data access issues.

A possible goal for this project could be a helper app that with the click of a button (maybe a browser extension) would (1) produce some kind of machine readable representation appended to the natural language version of the post (2) publish it using ActivityPub (AP) or other related network (3) possibly mirror it to Twitter if so desired.

Another possible client implementation could be a Zotero plug-in. For example, moving an item to a particular folder or adding a particular note/tag to it could trigger the corresponding AP publishing event.

Regarding data schema we can possibly use [Schema.org](http://Schema.org) schemas such as [https://schema.org/ReactAction](https://schema.org/ReactAction), [https://schema.org/ReviewAction](https://schema.org/ReviewAction)

File:Tweet.png

2022-11-09T09:28:48Z

Ronent:

Researcher tweeting that they want to read a particular paper.

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-08T16:16:31Z

Ronent:

== Federated Linked Attention Data Publishing ==
Lead: Ronen Tamari

Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub

2022-11-08T16:14:47Z

Ronent: Created page with "TODO"

TODO

Project Ideas

2022-11-08T16:13:58Z

Ronent: /* Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub */

== [[Translate Logseq Knowledge Graph to Systems Biology Network Diagrams]] ==
lead: [[Akila Wijerathna-Yapa]]

== [[Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub]] ==

{{Message
|Author=sneakers-the-rat
|Avatar=https://cdn.discordapp.com/avatars/305044217393053697/2970b22bd769d0cd0ee1de79be500e85.png?size=1024
|Date Sent=22-11-03 22:51:30
|Channel=In terms of overlap with my own
|Text=[[Project Ideas#Linked Data Publishing On Activitypub]]

ooh I'm very interested in this. so are you thinking a [[Twitter#Bridge]] -> [[ActivityPub#Bridge]] where one could use markup within the twitter post to declare [[Linked Data#Markup Syntax]] and then post to AP? I have thought about this kind of thing before, like using a bot command syntax to declare prefixes by doing something like
```
@ bot prefix
foaf: https:// (ontology URL)
```
or
```
@ bot alias
term: foaf.LongerNameForTerm
```
so that one could do maybe a semantic wikilink like `[ [term::value] ]` either within the tweet or as a reply to it (so the tweet itself doesn't become cluttered/it can become organized post -hoc?).

I've also thought about a bridge (I called [[Threadodo]] ) that implements that kind of command syntax to be able to directly archive threads to [[Zenodo]] along with structured information about the author, but this seems more interesting.

I can help try and clear some of the groundwork out of the way to make it easier for you and other interested participants to experiment. I have asked around fedi a bunch for a very minimal AP server implementation, and I could try and find one (or we could try and prototype one) if you want to experiment with that :), and I can also document and show you a tweepy-based bot that has an extensible command/parsing system too
|Link=https://discord.com/channels/1029514961782849607/1037786518800039978/1037861609885925467
}}